View more cities |
View 7 day forecast
News Headlines
 

START: Picture:

Clinton visit ‘should be a debate, not a lecture’

US should not top agenda with governance issues, expert warns
Published: 2009/08/06 06:45:31 AM

THE government should use the visit by US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton to discuss serious issues of economic trade and conflict resolution in Africa rather than be lectured by her on matters of good governance, says Prof Shadrack Gutto of the Centre for African Renaissance in Pretoria.

Clinton’s seven-nation African safari will reach South African shores tonight with discussions on the strengthening of diplomatic ties between the newly elected administrations in both countries, scheduled to resume tomorrow .

Gutto said SA should also put on the table issues to which it wishes the US to respond positively. These include the Darfur conflict and taking seriously the Durban review conference in Geneva, Switzerland, which evaluated progress towards the goals set by the World Conference against Racism, Racial Discrimination, Xenophobia and Related Intolerance held in Durban in 2001.

On Zimbabwe, President Barack Obama’s ambassadorial nominee to SA, Donald Gips, has already urged the US to work with SA , saying the global political agreement (GPA) that established a unity government heralded “guarded optimism that better times may be ahead for Zimbabwe”. But Clinton is expected to push SA to do more.

Under the Bush administration, SA was at pains to convince the US to give former president Thabo Mbeki ’s mediation process a chance.

Analyst Dirk Kotzé said Clinton was expected to encourage SA to use its leadership role in the Southern African Development Community and as a guarantor of the GPA “to address the outstanding issues that threaten to derail the process (in Zimbabwe)”.

The US seemed determined, Kotzé said, to continue to respect SA’s role as the economic engine of sub- Saharan Africa and the fact that SA’s prosperity is critical to the continent’s economic and political stability.

Relations could be even better if the US were to persuade “SA to emphasise issues such as respect for human rights, the rule of law and good governance” in the region and on the continent, Kotzé said.

Clinton began her 11-day Africa tour in Kenya, the country of birth of Obama’s father, where the US has brought pressure to bear for the government’s failure to ensure justice for the victims of last year’s post-election violence. The US believes Nairobi should establish an independent tribunal to hold accountable the perpetrators if Kenya’s stability and economic development is to be ensured.

After SA, Clinton will travel to Angola, the Democratic Republic of Congo, Nigeria, Liberia and Cape Verde. Human rights movements have asked Clinton to call on the Angolan government to end arbitrary detention and torture in Cabinda, its oil-rich northern enclave.

They also want her to push for the prosecution of all military personnel who committed acts of sexual violence in the Congo. With AFP

radebeh@bdfm.co.za

Post comment here (You must login first)   Login | Register
All comments are moderated and will be posted only if they are about the subject and are not abusive, vulgar and/or discriminatory
Article Tools
Print
By: charliezap On: Aug 6 2009 2:50PM
What's to debate? South Africa seems to have an inability to learn, whether from the failure of policies under Mbeki (African diplomatic adventures, especially Zimbabwe; AIDS; corruption and incompetence in state-run enterprises and other high places; crime). Zuma does not seem to have done anything to address these issues so far.
By: 289@Walkerville On: Aug 6 2009 12:37PM
Prof Shadrack Gutto of the Centre for African Renaissance in Pretoria makes an intriguing point. Daily we see in this newspaper and others, reports of corruption at all levels of government, which coupled to incompetence serve to impede service delivery and corrode our new democracy in a whole host of ways. So while I do see value in the kind of debate he suggests, surely there is even greater value for our leaders to be told in diplomatic but no uncertain terms that it is time they did something to rescue good governance in the New South Africa before it is too late, rather than make ineffectual noises while continuing to line their pockets. After all Ms Clinton would be saying no more than Nelson Mandela did at Addis Abba more than ten years back and it would appear that his statements then in this regard do indeed bear repetition. Their hands may not be entirely clean but if the leaders of the great democracies do not speak out on this issue, who will? And, after all, they above others do have the advantage of the certainty of being heard. The message I get from Prof. Gutto's (reported) comments is that only "comfortable" subjects should be discussed that do not disturb our leaders from continuing to generate with apparent impunity the headlines we now seem to read daily. For as long as we have a relatively free press that is. I would be intrigued to know if this is the message he intended.
 
 


 
Featured Top Stories
National
World
Companies
Markets
Economy & Business
Sport
Motoring
Lifestyle
Tech
JSE Today Commodities Currencies
 
Find Share
 
 
Editor's Picks
 
Most Read Most Commented
 
Services & Updates
Follow us on Twitter
Top stories
Register for:
-Daily Newsletter
-Article Comments
-My Portfolio
Subscribe to:
-Print Publications
-News Headlines
 (SMS BDNEWS to 31899)
 


Subscribe  |  Advertise  |  Contact Us  |  Register  |  SiteMap  |  NewsLetter

Financial Mail   |  Summit TV   |  Bignews   |  Netassets   |  I-Net Bridge   |  Business Media in Education   |  Pearson Plc   |  Avusa

BDFM Publishers (Pty) Ltd disclaims all liability for any loss, damage, injury or expense however caused, arising from the use of or reliance upon, in any manner, the information provided through
this service and does not warrant the truth, accuracy or completeness of the information provided.
online publishers association member Proudly Part of Avusa Privacy Policy
Copyright © 2009 BDFM Publishers (Pty) Ltd. All Rights Reserved