When US President Donald Trump pledged to investigate large-scale killings of white farmers in SA and violent takeovers of land, Pretoria said he was misinformed. Elsewhere, there was quiet satisfaction.
For activist group AfriForum, Trump’s intervention, following a Fox News show criticising the land-reform plans of the ANC, signalled a job well done.
“The best possible outcome that we hoped for was for a statement by the president of the USA, which we got,” said AfriForum deputy CEO Ernst Roets.
The walls in his Pretoria office display photographs of street protests by AfriForum, stepped up in 2018 against land distribution plans and what it calls the targeted killing of white farmers.
Of 20,000 murders in the last recorded year, 46 were white people killed on farms, according to police data. No land has been seized and the vast majority of victims are poor and black.
Ramaphosa’s vague pledge in 2018 to pursue land expropriation without compensation to right the wrongs of apartheid has given new impetus to AfriForum and its mother body, Solidarity, that have brushed aside his insistence he will protect property rights. Critics, including some prominent Afrikaners, accuse the groups of stirring racial fears at a time when Ramaphosa is trying to defuse threats of unrest from the EFF.
Solidarity says it reflects fears rather than stirring them. “On expropriation, they can’t threaten that sort of thing and not expect a reaction,” Flip Buys, chair of the umbrella movement, said by telephone. “Some battles you must fight. We must save the country from what happened in Zimbabwe,” he said, referring to the widespread violent takeover of white-owned farms in the early 2000s.
More fringe white groups, including the survivalist Suidlanders, have been warning for decades that Afrikaners are under threat. But Solidarity and AfriForum are working at a different level, holding prominent protests, lobbying foreign governments and preparing to approach the UN to request land expropriation be recognised as a breach of human rights.
AfriForum and Cope, a party formed by dissident ANC members with three seats in parliament, said they met senior US embassy officials on Monday to ask Washington to put pressure on SA to protect property rights. The US embassy said Cope and AfriForum delivered a petition to one of its officials.
Conversations with a dozen members of AfriForum at its rallies and elsewhere, reviews of its social media accounts and private text messages sent by its members reveal an increasingly influential movement with an agenda that divides SA.
Roets had appeared on Tucker Carlson’s Fox News show in May where they spoke about what they called targeted killings of white farmers and plans to take land along racial lines. The government, academics and a wide range of commentators say neither is happening, but right-wing journalists from Canada, Britain and Australia have made programmes on the issue.
“AfriForum has understood this emergence of white chauvinist identities around the world and is manipulating it for its own ends,” said Adam Habib, vice-chancellor of Wits University. “The problem with that is it will fracture our communities.”
Columnist Max du Preez says AfriForum does not represent the Afrikaans community and does it a disservice by making it seem racist. “If black people want to insult an Afrikaner they call him AfriForum,” he said.
Roets denies AfriForum preys on white people’s fears and says it is employing the same tactics the ANC used in the 1980s to put pressure on the apartheid government. “We learnt from the best. We have found the South African government is very sensitive to international criticism.”
Trump’s intervention stole the limelight during Ramaphosa’s high-profile visit to the UN General Assembly in September. Ramaphosa made light of Trump’s comments but an ANC source said he was very angry. Every president in democratic SA has tried, and largely failed, to redress an imbalance whereby whites — 9% of 56-million South Africans — own more than 70% of agricultural land.
Ramaphosa is competing in the 2019 elections with the EFF exploiting anger at persistent rural destitution among blacks alongside wealthy, white-owned commercial farms. The party has threatened to nationalise all land and urged people to occupy it — calls which have so far gone unheeded beyond a few groups erecting shacks on unused plots.
Ramaphosa has said reforms will not harm the economy, investment or food security and that unused land in towns and cities would be a high priority. He has given few details, but has the support of most big businesses and foreign investor community.
Trump’s tweet unnerved investors and drove down the rand and share prices, though they subsequently recovered. “I have asked Secretary of State @SecPompeo to closely study the SA land and farm seizures and expropriations and the large scale killing of farmers,” it said.
A US embassy spokesperson said it was continuing to evaluate various issues, including land, as normal. Solidarity is made up of about 20 organisations, including a media company, a university and an investment fund. Its 500,000 members pay fees and a property portfolio and stock market investments are among other funding sources.
Reuters spoke to AfriForum members who believe the Afrikaner community is under threat and feels Solidarity is the only support network they can rely on. Some described Solidarity as a “state within a state”.
Roets said AfriForum’s membership was growing but it had no intention of trying to carve out a de-facto white state. “There are certain buzzwords that we like to use and we encourage among our membership and those are words like ‘self-reliance’ like ‘self-help’ like ‘independence’,” he said. “If you want to describe that as a ‘state within a state’ that’s fine.”
The Suidlanders, meanwhile, are preparing for battle. In an isolated outpost town on the Orange River, they say they expect an “imminent” racial civil war. Hoarding guns, clothes and food in bunkers hidden in the dry barren landscape, its growing membership has drawn up a detailed plan to carve off a section of the country.
“Some people think we are racists. It’s totally not the case. We are purely and simply a civil defence organisation,” Suidlanders spokesperson Simon Roche said.
Roche, who showed Reuters caravans filled with supplies ready for when “war” breaks out, says he has travelled to Washington and Europe to meet with like-minded groups and with politicians, though he declined to name them. “We must tell the world what is coming. People can call us conspiracy theorists. Soon we will see who was right.”
Reuters
Would you like to comment on this article?
Sign up (it's quick and free) or sign in now.
Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.