Sean Summers’ return to Pick n Pay was greeted with scepticism and a flurry of cheap quips about a “pensioner” CEO. Two years on, those jibes look premature.
The half-year results and the programme he has run show disciplined diagnosis, smart prioritisation and the hard graft that turns strategic talk into measurable recovery.
The Cape Town-based company posted almost R60bn in turnover in the six months to the end of August, about 5% higher than the same time a year earlier. A lot flowed to the bottom line, helping it post a 56% narrower headline loss to R439m. Net finance costs dropped to R627m, a decline of almost 45%.
The repair job at Pick n Pay deserves a measured share of credit. The turnaround so far is evidence-led, operationally focused and pragmatic — the exact medicine the group needed.
Summers captures that shift with his remark that “we’re not in a race to become the biggest again … the market is finite at the end of the day. It’s not infinite. And it’s not a race just to see how many stores you can open … it’s profitability, also the quality of your real estate that’s very important.” It is about quality profitability per site, not vanity metrics of footprint.
Summers began by buying time. He stabilised the balance sheet, reduced funding pressure and cut the immediate cost of capital. That did not solve the structural problems, sure, but it changed the starting point. His executive team could stop fighting liquidity and start fixing the businesses. A sharper interest bill and a healthier runway turned what looked like a fraught stewardship into an actionable reset rather than a holding pattern.
Once the balance sheet showed breathing room, Summers attacked the estate, the most obvious source of value leakage. Pick n Pay carried a legacy portfolio of loss-making company stores that diluted margins and consumed management attention. His play was blunt and sensible: close or convert structurally weak outlets and accelerate Boxer’s rollout where the economics are demonstrably stronger.
That pattern is important because recoveries founded on margin repair and store productivity are more likely to last than those driven by temporary price or volume promotions.
Operationally, he tightened execution across the value chain. Inventory discipline, fewer margin-eroding promotions and a return to gross margin focus reduced like-for-like improvements that show up in trading profit, not just turnover. That pattern is important because recoveries founded on margin repair and store productivity are more likely to last than those driven by temporary price or volume promotions.
Capital allocations shifted towards those that can potentially generate returns. Summers signalled R2.2bn of capex for the year, concentrated in Boxer, Pick n Pay Clothing and selective supermarket upgrades. Boxer posted the fastest sales growth in the industry, and remains the group’s engine, Pick n Pay Clothing opened its 400th standalone store and grew turnover by double digits. Redirecting scarce investment towards higher return formats is an admission that not every corner of the empire deserves equal funding.
Summers’ bounded ambitions — “the market is finite” — steady staff, suppliers and investors by resetting success metrics away from store count towards margins and cash generation. That clarity is itself a governance win because it reduces operational drift and aligns the organisation behind a smaller set of measurable priorities.
That process is real, to be sure, but it is conditional. For one thing, the store estate reset carries social and labour fallout, meaning Summers might show credible measures to limit protracted conflict. For another, Boxer’s performance is promising, but the true test is sustaining unit economics as the chain scales by dozens more sites.
Summers has earned a measured bouquet because he traded managerial vanity for surgical fixes. Those are indispensable first moves of any credibility turnaround. They do not guarantee success, but they move Pick n Pay from slow decline into recovery.
Would you like to comment on this article?
Sign up (it's quick and free) or sign in now.
Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.